By Ali Odowaa
Sunday October 22, 2023
President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud's recent allusion to a significant shift in Somalia's political structure, namely the adoption of a two-party system and the replacement of the position of Prime Minister with that of Vice President, has ignited a debate about the future of Somali governance. In response, it is crucial to assess whether these proposed changes are a step in the right direction or if, as the Somali proverb goes, they stand for a "jug-jug meeshaada joog" or a mistaken path.
As we evaluate these proposed changes, it is essential to recognize that the Somali political landscape has been historically complex, marked by clan dynamics, conflict, and efforts to set up a stable, inclusive democracy. The Somali proverb "jug-jug meeshaada joog" encapsulates the idea that these changes could lead down a misguided path.
In this short paper, I will outline several reasons why the proposed changes may be detrimental to the country's political and social fabric, highlighting the need to carefully consider their implications.
• A two-party system, if not carefully designed, may inadvertently lead to exclusion rather than inclusivity. Historically, clan affiliations have played a significant role in Somali politics. Reducing the number of political parties could concentrate power among the dominant clans, potentially sidelining smaller and historically marginalized communities.
• The replacement of the Prime Minister with a Vice President could weaken the checks and balances within the government. The Prime Minister traditionally held a key role in governance, representing different political interests and ensuring diverse perspectives in decision-making. Such a change might reduce the breadth of representation and accountability in the executive branch.
• The Somali political landscape has been plagued by clan-based politics, which have at times fueled division and conflict. A two-party system could inadvertently reinforce these divisions if the parties align with specific clans, risking the perpetuation of historical injustices and clan favoritism.
• Somalia's diverse population and complex social fabric call for a multiparty system to accommodate a wide range of perspectives and policy approaches. Restricting the political arena to only two parties may limit the diversity of ideas and stifle innovation, hampering efforts to address the country's multifaceted challenges.
• To move forward, Somalia needs policies and institutions that promote national unity, transcending clan affiliations. Changes that might inadvertently deepen clan-based divisions, such as a two-party system, could hinder progress toward a more unified and cohesive nation.
In conclusion, while President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud's proposed changes aim to reform Somalia's political structure, it is essential to carefully consider their implications. The historical complexities and clan-based dynamics need a cautious approach that prioritizes inclusivity, representation, and the overarching goal of a more united and prosperous Somalia. The Somali proverb "jug-jug meeshaada joog" serves as a reminder that, in this critical juncture, the path chosen must be one that leads to a brighter and more stable future for all Somali citizens.
Ali Odowaa is a Canadian of Somali descent and public policy commentator.
He can be reached @
[email protected]